ActiveSUFFOLK COUNTY · SCHOOL & HOME SEARCH
Shelter Island School
Homes for sale.
Shelter Island Union Free School District
KNOW THE SCHOOL
A starting point
for your move.
- School district
- Shelter Island Union Free School District
- Reported grades
- Pre-K, K, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12
- Campus address
- 33 N Ferry Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964
Grades source: NCES 2025–26 preliminary directory. Campus and identity: NCES 2025–26 preliminary directory, with current official sources where noted. NCES school ID: 362664003632.
CURRENT MLS MATCHES
Explore the homes.
24 active residential listings · Newest first
For-sale residential listings only, in Nassau or Suffolk County, with an exact reviewed school and district match. The school field may be incomplete or outdated. This is not an attendance boundary map.
Active
Active5 Marc
$1,999,999
Active61 Cartwright Road
$2,230,000
Active2 Bayview Avenue
$3,895,000
Active7 Wheeler Road
$2,690,000
Active13 Spring Garden Avenue
$2,995,000
Active11 Jaspa Road
$1,250,000
Active169 Ferry Road
$4,250,000
Active6 Great Circle Drive
$4,995,000
Active64A Midway Road
$2,199,000
Active11 Prospect Avenue
$2,200,000
Active6 Oxford Avenue
$1,495,000
Active5 Sea Gull Road
$3,795,000
Active43 Gardiners Bay Drive
$3,290,000
Active16 Bowditch Road
$999,999
Active90 Peconic Avenue
$4,800,000
Active4 Irene Lane
$1,850,000
Active11 Mimosa Place
$1,275,000
Active11 Sunnyside Avenue
$5,000,000
Active9 Locust Woods Drive
$2,995,000
Active14 Freds Lane
$2,239,000
Active12 Terry Dr.
$2,800,000
Active8 Hilo Drive
$3,850,000
Active