Back to results

Active

2 Bayview Avenue

Shelter Island Heights, NY, 11965

$3,895,000
4Bedrooms
7Bathrooms
5,377Interior sq ft
1Acres
2018Year built

AN INTRODUCTION

A closer look.

Welcome to 2 Bayview Ave, a stunning modern home nestled in the serene, walkable streets of Shelter Island Heights, NY. This corner lot property boasts an expansive acre of bucolic land, offering a tranquil escape. The exterior of the home features large front and back porches with ample overhangs for three season comfort. Mahogany decking, porcelain tiles, integrated speakers and overhead fans enhance the enjoyment of picturesque surroundings. The raised backyard is a very private sanctuary of its own with a 16 x 40 gunite pool, a cozy cabana and lush greenery, creating an oasis for relaxation or entertaining. Step inside to a spacious open floor plan accentuated by 10-foot ceilings and a stunning 15ft x 20ft custom window wall that bathes the home in natural southern light. Wide-plank light oak flooring and a cohesive palette of contrasting trim elements evoke a Nordic design language throughout. The custom kitchen is a chef's dream, complete with an oversized quartz island, copious storage, a Thermador appliance suite, and a convenient walk-in pantry. The home is designed for comfortable everyday living and effortless entertaining. Down a windowed hall and separated from the entertaining areas of the home, the primary suite on the main level is a haven of comfort, featuring a large walk-in closet and a luxurious bathroom with double sinks on a floating vanity, a private toilet room and multi-fixture wet room. The main level also houses a convenient laundry room, a powder room, extra closets and a versatile bonus space with its own rear-patio entrance and an attached full bathroom. Upstairs, a cozy, windowed loft space overlooks the main living area. A bright hall joins three additional en-suite bedrooms, including a junior primary suite. Each bath boasts fine fixtures and marble work. The finished lower level provides valuable additional space for recreation, a home gym, media room or overflowing living with a full bathroom and walk-out level access to a private covered patio offers endless potential for customization. The property also includes a 3-car garage – a true rarity in Shelter Island Heights – elegantly situated below the sightlines of the home’s main living areas, thus preserving views of the beautifully landscaped surroundings. A secondary driveway that serves the garage features custom board-formed retaining walls, exquisite plantings and warm landscape lighting that add to the property's striking visual impression. 2 Bayview Ave. is more than just a home; it's a lifestyle. It's a place where modern luxury meets the tranquility of nature.

Property overview

Property type
Single Family Residence
Architecture
Modern
Year built
2018
Lot size (sq ft)
43,560
Status
Active
Listed
2026-10-08
MLS number
KEY1059229

Interior & comfort

Interior features
First Floor Bedroom, First Floor Full Bath, Cathedral Ceiling(s), Ceiling Fan(s), Chandelier, Chefs Kitchen, Double Vanity, Eat-in Kitchen, Entrance Foyer, Galley Type Kitchen, High Ceilings, Kitchen Island, Marble Counters, Open Floorplan, Open Kitchen, Pantry, Primary Bathroom, Master Downstairs, Quartz/Quartzite Counters, Recessed Lighting, Smart Thermostat, Soaking Tub, Sound System, Speakers, Storage, Walk-In Closet(s)
Appliances
Convection Oven, Dishwasher, Dryer, Exhaust Fan, Freezer, Gas Range, Microwave, Refrigerator, Stainless Steel Appliance(s), Washer, Tankless Water Heater
Heating
Forced Air, Propane
Cooling
Central Air
Basement
Full, Partially Finished
Fireplaces
0

Outdoors & amenities

Parking
Private
Garage spaces
3
Pool
In Ground
Waterfront
Beach Access

Schools & location

Postal town
Shelter Island Heights
County
Suffolk County
School district
Shelter Island
Elementary school
Shelter Island School
Middle school
Shelter Island School
High school
Shelter Island School

Taxes & utilities

Annual property taxes
$16,436
Tax year
2026
Association
Yes
Association fee
$9,782
Fee frequency
Annually
Water
Public
Sewer
Public Sewer

Listing courtesy of Douglas Elliman Real Estate · 631-354-8100
MLS #KEY1059229 · Active

LET’S CONNECT

Arrange a showing.

Share your preferred dates and any questions. We’ll follow up to confirm availability.

Prefer to talk? 516.888.9711

We’ll use these details to respond to your inquiry. Your message is sent securely through our email provider, Resend. Please don’t include sensitive financial information.