Huntington’s historic Old Town Hall on Main Street. Photo: DanTD / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0. Cropped; headline added by The Pesce & Lanzillotta Group.
By Mike Pesce & Ron Lanzillotta, The Pesce & Lanzillotta Group, Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Laffey International Realty
Last week we walked through the Town of Huntington’s proposed 2027 budget and its 18.4 percent increase in the town tax levy. On Tuesday night, November 17, that plan changed dramatically. The Town Board approved a last-minute package of amendments that removed the steep increase, and the amended budget is now projected to come in at or under the state tax cap.
If you own a home in Huntington, Dix Hills, Melville, Cold Spring Harbor, Lloyd Harbor or Lloyd Neck, or you are thinking about buying in the town, here is what happened, what is still being finalized, and what it means for your next property tax bill.
What Happened at Tuesday’s Meeting
Councilwoman Theresa Mari brought 39 amendments to the preliminary budget, HuntingtonNow reported. Newsday reported that the amendments cut the proposed 2027 tax levy by $22.5 million, bringing the budget under New York’s tax cap, in part by delaying the filling of 24 vacant positions. HuntingtonNow reported that many of the changes relied on revised projections of revenues and expenses, including how snow removal costs are estimated, along with deferring other costs.
Mari said she had two goals: avoiding job eliminations if possible and making no service cuts to residents. She blamed unfunded state mandates and the rising cost of living for the pressure on the budget.
Each amendment passed by a vote of three in favor with two abstentions. Supervisor Ed Smyth and Councilwoman Brooke Lupinacci abstained, saying the amendment documents reached them only about two hours before the meeting.
Then came the twist. The board voted 3-2 against the overall budget. Mari and Councilman David Bennardo voted yes. Supervisor Smyth, Councilwoman Lupinacci and Councilwoman Jennifer Hebert voted no. Hebert said she had supported the amendments but could not approve the final budget because the process needed to improve and the public needed to be involved earlier.
So Is There a Budget?
Yes. According to HuntingtonNow, the amended budget, which is projected to meet the state tax cap, takes effect under state law because the town cannot operate without one. The town’s own budget calendar notes that a budget must be adopted on or before November 20.
The final budget figure was not available Tuesday night. HuntingtonNow reported that more details were expected Wednesday and that the final budget must be delivered to the state by Friday. We will update this post as the town releases final numbers.
How Big a Change Is This?
The preliminary budget totaled about $269.7 million, with spending up 9.9 percent and the tax levy up 18.4 percent. HuntingtonNow reported the town’s estimate that, if it had passed, the average homeowner would have paid about $356 more per year on the town portion of the tax bill.
For context, the town’s preliminary budget book put the 2027 allowable levy increase under the state tax cap at 2.68 percent. With the amended budget projected at or under the cap, the town’s share of a typical bill is expected to rise far less than first proposed.
Not everyone is pleased. Highway Superintendent Andre Sorrentino said the amendments reduce his operating budget by $3 million. “Reducing my operating budget by $3 million directly impacts my ability to fulfill that responsibility,” he said in a statement to HuntingtonNow.
What This Means for Huntington Homeowners
Keep the full bill in perspective. The town levy is only one piece of a Huntington property tax bill, which also includes school district, county and special district taxes. A smaller town increase is welcome news, but it is not the whole picture. If you live in an incorporated village such as Lloyd Harbor, you also pay village taxes.
A few practical steps:
- Watch for the final numbers. The town is expected to release the final budget this week.
- Check your assessment and exemptions. Make sure the town has your home’s details right and that you receive any exemptions you qualify for, such as STAR or senior exemptions.
- Keep an eye on services. Delayed hiring and a smaller highway budget could show up in day-to-day services like roads and snow removal. Those quality-of-life details matter to buyers, too.
What It Means for Buyers and Sellers
Buyers: Predictable taxes make it easier to plan a monthly budget. When you compare homes in Dix Hills, Melville, Huntington or Cold Spring Harbor, ask for the current tax bill on every property, and remember that school district taxes vary from one district to the next.
Sellers: A headline about an 18 percent tax increase can make buyers nervous. Now you can tell them that increase did not happen. Have your latest tax bill and a list of your exemptions ready, and note that some exemptions may not transfer to a new owner.
“Huntington residents spoke up, and this outcome gives homeowners and buyers a little more clarity heading into the new year. Taxes are one piece of the picture when you buy or sell, and Mike and I are always glad to sit down with you and walk through what it all means for your home and your plans.”
— Ron Lanzillotta, The Pesce & Lanzillotta Group
Thinking About Buying or Selling in the Town of Huntington?
From Lloyd Harbor and Cold Spring Harbor to Dix Hills and Melville, we help buyers and sellers understand the full cost of owning a home, taxes included, before they make a move. Reach Mike Pesce or Ron Lanzillotta at 516.888.9711 or info@pl-team.com.
Mike Pesce & Ron Lanzillotta, The Pesce & Lanzillotta Group | Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Laffey International Realty | 8223 Jericho Turnpike, Woodbury | 516.888.9711 | info@pl-team.com
Related reading: Long Island’s October 2026 home prices. Request your home valuation or talk with our team.
Sources
- HuntingtonNow: Huntington Will Get Amended Budget, Stripped of 18 Percent Tax Increase, November 17–18, 2026
- Newsday: Huntington Town will have leaner budget, lower tax levy after residents’ outrage over earlier proposed increases, November 18, 2026 (summary via Beloud)
- News 12 Long Island: Town of Huntington fails to pass 18% tax increase, November 17, 2026
- HuntingtonNow: Huntington Town Board to Vote on 2027 Budget
- Town of Huntington: 2027 Preliminary Budget, budget message and calendar

Contact 
