Back to results

Active

5 Shore Drive

Setauket, NY, 11733

$2,350,000
4Bedrooms
3Bathrooms
2,800Interior sq ft
3.94Acres
1975Year built

AN INTRODUCTION

A closer look.

Wake up to the water every day. A rare waterfront sancturary that's nearly impossible to find at this price - 4 acres of unparalleled serenity on Flax Pond with mature trees, fig trees, room for a pool! Launch your kayak, watch magnificent sunsets! Pure tranquility, beyond the ordinary. Waterfront living surrounded by nature's finest beauty. Flax Pond Prestige! A waterfront home that shines in every season - 111' of waterfront frontage - One irreplaceable Setting! Set back from the road and positioned on the most sought-after waterfront views of Flax Pond, Crane Neck and the LI Sound with beach access! The home, once a cabin hunting lodge in the 20's was purchased by Mr. Walcott, a Professor of Biology from SUNY Stony Brook in the 60's. A New England native, Mr. Walcott purposely instructed the architect to design a house to appear as an older Saltbox-style home which expanded gradually over many years; hence the multiple roof levels and somewhat irregular layout. While some internal modernization has been undertaken by the present owners, the original character of this house has been respected. Updates include; French drain in basement, filters added to the well, central air conditioning system, inground sprinkler system, Generator, SS kitchen appliances, newer oil burner. The southern meadow, meanwhile, became partially forested and transformed into a scenic lawn, both home to local wildlife, while the northern lawn has reliably served as a front lawn, bird sanctuary, and a thorough and reliable protection against the sea. Bird watch, commune with nature and enjoy the harmony of water and wilderness, experiencing the best of both worlds. A home so warm and welcoming. The house is the bonus....the waterfront is the prize!

Property overview

Property type
Single Family Residence
Architecture
Other
Condition
Actual
Year built
1975
Lot size (sq ft)
171,626
Status
Active
Listed
2026-03-23
MLS number
KEY960930

Interior & comfort

Interior features
Breakfast Bar, Built-in Features, Eat-in Kitchen, Entrance Foyer, Formal Dining, High Speed Internet, Natural Woodwork, Recessed Lighting
Appliances
Dishwasher, Dryer, Gas Range, Microwave, Other, Stainless Steel Appliance(s), Washer
Heating
Baseboard, Oil
Cooling
Central Air
Basement
Full, Unfinished
Fireplaces
4

Outdoors & amenities

Exterior features
Garden
Parking
Attached, Driveway, Garage, Private
Garage spaces
2
Waterfront
Beach Access, Pond, Sound, Water Access, Waterfront
Views
Panoramic, Water

Schools & location

Postal town
Setauket
County
Suffolk County
School district
Three Village
Elementary school
Setauket Elementary School
Middle school
Paul J Gelinas Junior High School
High school
Ward Melville Senior High School

Taxes & utilities

Annual property taxes
$40,877
Tax year
2026
Association
Yes
Association fee
$1,132
Fee frequency
Annually
Water
Well
Sewer
Cesspool

Listing courtesy of Jolie Powell Realty Inc · 631-473-0420
MLS #KEY960930 · Active

LET’S CONNECT

Ask about this home.

Have a question or want to see it in person? Send a quick note and we’ll follow up.

About: 5 Shore Drive, Setauket

Ron Lanzillotta and Michael Pesce

Personal guidance from our local team.
Read our client experiences

Prefer to talk? 516.888.9711

Add a note or phone number (optional)

We’ll use your details to respond to this request. No marketing signup. Please don’t include sensitive financial information.