Sunrise Mall sign and parking lot, Massapequa, New York. Photo: Oganguly / Wikimedia Commons, CC0. Headline overlay by The Pesce & Lanzillotta Group.
By Mike Pesce & Ron Lanzillotta, The Pesce & Lanzillotta Group, Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Laffey International Realty
For anyone who grew up in Massapequa, the Sunrise Mall was a Saturday ritual. Today the building sits empty off Sunrise Highway, and the biggest question for the neighborhoods around it is what comes next. Last week that question got a lot more concrete.
On Thursday, November 12, the Town of Oyster Bay's Planning Advisory Board heard a proposal to build an Amazon warehouse and vehicle fleet service building on part of the old mall property. The board didn't vote that night. Here's what's proposed, where the review stands and what it could mean if you own a home nearby or you're thinking about buying in Massapequa or Massapequa Park.
What Amazon Is Proposing
The board's November 12 agenda lists the application as Carmans Road, Massapequa (SP 25-462). The applicant is seeking site plan approval for a proposed 153,393-square-foot warehouse with an accessory vehicle fleet service building and related site improvements. The agenda states that the proposed use is a permitted use under the Town of Oyster Bay code.
That last point matters. Because the use is already allowed on the property, this review isn't about a zone change. It's about the details of the site plan: how the buildings are laid out, how vehicles get in and out, and how the project fits next to the surrounding streets.
The project would cover only part of the mall property, not the whole site. Urban Edge Properties, which bought the Sunrise Mall in 2021, reported in its September 30, 2026 SEC filing that it remained under contract to sell a parcel of the property for $75.9 million, subject to closing conditions and regulatory approvals. That filing described a pending transaction, not a completed sale.
What Happened at the November 12 Hearing
News 12 Long Island reported that the project team described the site as a delivery hub. "We've all come to appreciate the convenience of being able to order just about anything and have it delivered right to our homes… but what people don't necessarily think about is what happens behind the scenes to make that possible," one project leader said.
According to News 12, the team said Amazon delivery vans would come and go during off-peak hours and not in the middle of the night. They also said their traffic and environmental studies found the impact would be significantly less than the Sunrise Mall's when it was at its busiest, and that the site would add jobs.
Neighbors who spoke weren't convinced. "This warehouse does not fit into the scheme of our community," said Rachel Dinowitz, who lives near the mall. Resident Jim Shea told News 12, "The whole area is congested. It's a lot of stores. It's a lot of houses. And you're putting this big monster in the middle of it." Their biggest worries were noise and traffic. "We do want progress," Dinowitz said. "But we want it to benefit the people that pay the taxes and the people that want to live a quiet, healthy lifestyle."
The board postponed its vote because of a Microsoft Outlook outage that affected public comments sent by email, News 12 reported.
What Happens Next
According to the town's posted adjournment notice, as reported by local outlets, the site plan review moves to the Planning Advisory Board's Thursday, December 10 meeting at 7 p.m. in the Town Board Hearing Room at Town Hall North, 54 Audrey Avenue, Oyster Bay. A separate application to divide the mall property into four lots is on that agenda too.
Keep in mind that the advisory board doesn't make the final call. Per the town, the Planning Advisory Board reviews site plans and recommends approval or disapproval to the Town Board. So even a December recommendation would be one step in the process, not the finish line.
There's a second Massapequa land use item to watch this week, too. The Oyster Bay Town Board's November 17 agenda includes a resolution on the decision for a special use permit for a self-storage facility at 5596 Old Sunrise Highway, Massapequa.
What It Could Mean for Homeowners Nearby
Honestly, nobody can tell you today what an Amazon facility would do to the value of a specific house, and we'd be wary of anyone who claims to. What will matter are the details that come out of the review: where the entrances and exits go, which roads delivery vans use, operating hours, buffering and landscaping. Two homes a few blocks apart could feel the project very differently.
There's also another side to the story. A large, empty commercial property doesn't help a neighborhood either, and a clear, approved plan tends to be easier for buyers to understand than years of uncertainty. Where you land likely depends on how close you are and how you weigh convenience and jobs against traffic and noise.
What It Means for Buyers and Sellers
Buyers: If you're looking at homes near Sunrise Highway and the Carmans Road area, ask about the project and drive the surrounding roads at different times of day. Follow the December 10 meeting and any Town Board action so you understand what's planned before you commit.
Sellers: Buyers will ask about the mall, so it helps to be ready with the facts: what's proposed, what's been approved (nothing yet) and when the next decisions come. Pricing should be grounded in recent sales on your own streets, not in headlines.
"The Sunrise Mall holds a lot of memories for Massapequa families, so it's natural that people care deeply about what happens there next. If you live nearby and want to talk through what this could mean for your home, or you're weighing a move in Massapequa or Massapequa Park, Mike and I are always happy to sit down and help you sort through it."
— Ron Lanzillotta, The Pesce & Lanzillotta Group
Thinking About Buying or Selling in Massapequa?
From Massapequa and Massapequa Park to Syosset and the North Shore, we help buyers and sellers make sense of local news and what it means for their homes. Reach Mike Pesce or Ron Lanzillotta at 516.888.9711 or info@pl-team.com.
Mike Pesce & Ron Lanzillotta, The Pesce & Lanzillotta Group | Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Laffey International Realty | 8223 Jericho Turnpike, Woodbury | 516.888.9711 | info@pl-team.com
Explore Massapequa
Living in Massapequa · Our Massapequa town guide · Request your home valuation · Talk with our team
Sources
- News 12 Long Island: Amazon warehouse could be opening in old Sunrise Mall property, November 12, 2026
- Town of Oyster Bay: November 12 Planning Advisory Board agenda
- Town of Oyster Bay: Sunrise Mall adjournment notice
- Town of Oyster Bay: Planning Advisory Board calendar and role
- Urban Edge Properties: Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2026
- LI Daily: Sunrise Mall warehouse review moves to December 10
- Town of Oyster Bay: November 17, 2026 Town Board agenda

Contact 
